Homes & Land for Sale in Shelbyville, Illinois
Shelby Realty Services has 16 properties for sale in Shelbyville, Illinois (12 homes and 4 land listings), asking between $29,900 and $724,523, with 3 recently sold properties on record.
Shelbyville is the Shelby County seat and the town at the south end of Lake Shelbyville, a US Army Corps of Engineers reservoir with marinas, campgrounds and public beaches within a few minutes of the courthouse square. IL-16 and IL-128 meet here.
Every listing below is a Shelby Realty Services property with full photos, details and a direct line to the listing agent. We have worked this area since 1973 — call (855) 215-3400 and we will tell you what is coming up before it reaches the portals.
- For sale now
- 16
- Asking range
- $30K–$725K
- Property mix
- 12 / 4
- Recently sold
- 3
homes / land
For sale in Shelbyville
For Sale$39,900
LOT 3 1775 Road, Shelbyville
4 Acres
For Sale$724,523
1800 E 700 North Road, Shelbyville
74.31 Acres
For Sale$310,000
2439 E 1500 North Road, Shelbyville
3 Beds · 2 Baths · 1,376 Sq Ft · 5.01 Acres
For Sale$199,000
1509 W North First Street, Shelbyville
3 Beds · 2 Baths · 1,850 Sq Ft · 0.26 Acres
For Sale$59,000
515 W South 10th Street, Shelbyville
2 Beds · 1 Bath · 728 Sq Ft · 0.11 Acres
For Sale$74,000
511 W South 10th Street, Shelbyville
2 Beds · 1 Bath · 784 Sq Ft · 0.11 Acres
Sale Pending$159,900
700 N Lodge Street, Shelbyville
2 Beds · 2 Baths · 1,736 Sq Ft · 0.17 Acres
For Sale$144,000
516 S 10th Street, Shelbyville
2 Beds · 2 Baths · 1,891 Sq Ft · 0.73 Acres
For Sale$49,900
601 W North 5th Street, Shelbyville
2 Beds · 1 Bath · 980 Sq Ft · 0.27 Acres
For Sale$74,000
814 South 10th Street, Shelbyville
2 Beds · 1 Bath · 784 Sq Ft · 0.14 Acres
For Sale$39,900
LOT 1 1150 North Road, Shelbyville
3.59 Acres
For Sale$69,900
613 W South 10th Street, Shelbyville
2 Beds · 1 Bath · 744 Sq Ft · 0.28 Acres
For Sale$29,900
220 N Wood Street, Shelbyville
0.17 Acres
For Sale$60,000
LOT 7 1775 Road, Shelbyville
6 Acres
For Sale$150,000
118 Main Street, Shelbyville
0.04 Acres
For Sale$49,900
1172 State Highway 128 Highway, Shelbyville
2 Beds · 1 Bath · 624 Sq Ft · 2 Acres
Recently sold in Shelbyville
Properties we have sold here. Sale prices are not published.
What has sold in Shelbyville
Every arm's-length sale recorded in the last 24 months — not just ours, and not an estimate.
- Homes
- $133,850
- Farms
- $350,000
- Lots
- $85,000
median of 290 recorded sales
Houses and residences
median of 25 recorded sales
Ground sold as farmland
median of 38 recorded sales
Vacant land and building sites
From PTAX-203 transfer declarations filed with the Illinois Department of Revenue and recorded by Shelby County. Sales between relatives, court-ordered sales and lender-owned sales are excluded, because they are not what a property is worth. A median is not an appraisal, and no single property is the median.
See the full Shelbyville market report — 272 sales, by size, age and bedroom count, year by year.
Thinking of selling in Shelbyville?
We have been listing and selling in this area since 1973. We will tell you what your property is realistically worth, not what you want to hear.