Shelby

Moultrie County market report

What homes sold for across Moultrie County over the last three years, from closed MLS sales.

Median sale price
$137,000
Median per sq ft
$99
Median days on market
13
Months of supply
1.5

309 sales · 15 homes on the market · 91.2% of listings soldListing counts as of 23 August 2026

Year by year

Median sale price by the year the sale closed. Each point rests on at least five sales; hover to see how many.

$0$40,738$81,475$122,213$162,9502000: $63,700 — 22 sales2000$63,7002001: $63,000 — 35 sales2001$63,0002002: $80,000 — 39 sales2002$80,0002003: $69,000 — 55 sales2003$69,0002004: $74,000 — 67 sales2004$74,0002005: $76,199 — 64 sales2005$76,1992006: $74,500 — 72 sales2006$74,5002007: $72,000 — 65 sales2007$72,0002008: $81,500 — 74 sales2008$81,5002009: $79,000 — 75 sales2009$79,0002010: $82,750 — 76 sales2010$82,7502011: $85,000 — 74 sales2011$85,0002012: $90,850 — 88 sales2012$90,8502013: $86,750 — 76 sales2013$86,7502014: $83,750 — 102 sales2014$83,7502015: $90,000 — 112 sales2015$90,0002016: $83,500 — 96 sales2016$83,5002017: $84,950 — 110 sales2017$84,9502018: $81,000 — 108 sales2018$81,0002019: $95,000 — 103 sales2019$95,0002020: $98,750 — 132 sales2020$98,7502021: $100,000 — 117 sales2021$100,0002022: $98,400 — 144 sales2022$98,4002023: $99,000 — 110 sales2023$99,0002024: $135,000 — 85 sales2024$135,0002025: $148,700 — 102 sales2025$148,7002026: $162,950 — 76 sales2026$162,950
Median sale price in Moultrie County by year

By town

Towns with at least five recent sales. A town missing from this list did not have enough sales to report without describing individual homes.

TownMedian pricePer sq ftDays on marketSales
Sullivan$145,000$10513185
Bethany$115,000$91863
Lovington$124,000$83927
Dalton City$126,200$921512
Gays$152,500$71610

What the market pays for

The same three years, split by what kind of home sold.

Bedrooms

BandMedianSales
1-2 bed$105,00072
3 bed$144,450168
4+ bed$197,00069

Size

BandMedianSales
under 1,000 sq ft$92,00032
1,000–1,499 sq ft$119,000131
1,500–1,999 sq ft$169,50077
2,000+ sq ft$270,00069

Age

BandMedianSales
built in the last 20 years$280,00023
20–50 years old$196,75084
50–100 years old$130,000129
over 100 years old$115,00073

What is your Moultrie County home worth?

A county median tells you about the market, not about your house. We will look at yours — its size, condition, and what comparable homes nearby actually sold for.

Get a valuation